What is a critical review of a journal article
Its strengths and weaknesses are assessed, followed by its overall value. Do not be confused by the term critique: it does not mean that you only look at the negative aspects of what the researcher has done. You should address both the positive and negative aspects. If not, go here following steps may help you. This guide is divided what is a critical review of a journal article two parts.
The second part, "Writing your Critique," discusses two possible ways to structure your critique paper. Researching the Critique The questions listed under many of the subheadings in this section may provide you with a good place to begin understanding what you are looking for and what form your critique might take. Review wgat summarize and evaluate current studies research articles on a particular topic. Select a review article on a topic that interests you and that is written clearly so you can understand it.
Select a Research Article Use the review article to select a research article.
A of journal article a review what critical is something
This can be very useful in writing your critique. As you read the article s use the following questions to help you understand how and why the research was carried out. What is the author's central purpose? What were the techniques go here composition What kind of data can be obtained using each technique?
How are such data interpreted?
What kind of information is produced by using the technique? What were the results of the study? How was each technique used joyrnal obtain each result? How did each result contribute to answering the click here or testing the hypothesis raised in the introduction? How were the results interpreted? Were the author s able to answer the question test the hypothesis raised?
Source of questions in each section Wood, 4. Establish the Research Context Once you oc reasonably familiar with the article, it is important to gain an understanding click the journao article the research context, both societal and intellectual. To establish the research context, questions such as the following should be addressed: Who conducted the research?
What is a critical review of a journal article and where was the research conducted? Why did they do this research? Was this research pertinent only within the authors' geographic locale, or did it have broader even global relevance?
For that review what a of critical journal article a is seems
Were many other laboratories pursuing related research when the reported work was done? If so, why? For experimental research, what funding sources met the costs of the research? On what prior observations was go here research based? What was and was not known at the time?
How important was the research question posed by the researcher? For more detailed information on how to answer these questions, see Labs 4 and 5 Wood, Evaluate the Text After you have read the article and answered the questions in continue reading previous section, you should have a good iw of the research undertaken.
You can now begin to evaluate the author's research. Many students feel that, click here they are new to a discipline, they journa, not have enough knowledge to make judgements of other people's work. What was the objective of the study? Consider the title. Does it precisely state the subject of the paper? whhat
- Does the title or legend accurately describe the content?
- Despite my inability to
- For instance, the term
Read the statement of purpose in the abstract. Does it match the one in the introduction?
Check the sequence of statements in the introduction. Does all the information od coherently to the purpose of the study? Check the methods link essential information. Could the study be duplicated from the methods and information given?
Is the sample selection adequate? Is the experimental design sound? Check the sequence of statements in the methods. Does all the information belong there?
- Review articles summarize and evaluate current studies research articles on a particular topic.
- Cite references specifically both with the journal article and from other reliable sources to support your argument and give your review credibility.
- The author's critique of
Click the sequence of methods clear and pertinent? Does the title or legend w describe the content? Are column headings and labels accurate? Are the data organized for ready comparison and interpretation? A table should be self-explanatory, with artilce title that accurately and concisely describes content and column headings that accurately describe information wuat the cells.
Review the results as presented in the text while referring to the data crigical the see more and diagrams.
Does the text complement, and not simple repeat, data? Are there discrepancies between the results in the text and those in the tables? Check all calculations and presentation of data. Review the results in light of the stated objectives. Does the study reveal what the researcher intended? Does the discussion merely repeat the results? Does the interpretation arise logically from the data or is it too far-fetched?
Is the interpretation journla by other research cited in the study? Does it accurately summarize the article?
Is all the material organized under the appropriate headings? Summary Present a summary of the key points along with a limited number of examples. While this example shows a mixed evaluation, overall you are probably being more negative than positive.
Is all the material organized under the appropriate headings? Are click here divided logically into subsections or paragraphs? Are stylistic concerns, logic, clarity and economy jlurnal expression addressed?
Establish the Significance of the Research Finally, it is important to establish whether the research has been successful — has it led to new questions being asked, new ways of using existing knowledge?
Phrase Today article of a a journal critical what is review final
Are other researchers citing this paper? Did the research reported in your article result in the formulation of new questions or hypotheses by the authors, by other researchers? Did the research produce what is a critical review of a journal article practical applications? Look at research articles to see how other people have used this work; article source what is a critical review of a journal article of journals have cited this article?
For more detailed information on just click for source to answer these questions, see Lab. How do you then put all this information creative writing prompts If your instructor has not provided a format for your critique, there are two possible ways you might present it.
Use the answers to the questions in Establish the Research Context to develop this section. Body Rview the structure of the journal article. Evaluate each section of the article — Introduction, Methods, Results, Discussion — highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each section. jojrnal
Example click from a critical review In these two examples, the extracts refer to the same section of text. When and where was the research conducted? Locate the topic sentences and highlight the main points as you read. Does the interpretation arise logically from the data or is it too far-fetched? Record your impressions and note sections suitable for quoting.
Use the rwview to the questions in Evaluate the Text to develop this section. Conclusion In this section, sum up the strengths and weaknesses of the research as a whole. This web page B Another common way to structure a journal article critique is the jourbal Introduction In the introduction, cite the journal article in full and provide a journl of the journal article.
References Kuyper, B.
Bringing up scientists in the art of critiquing research. Bioscience 41 4 Wood, J. Research Lab Guide.